Is Yahoo Booklist a Scam? A Detailed Review and Analysis

  • Post author:
  • Post published:February 13, 2024
  • Post category:Reviews

Yahoo Booklist has been gaining popularity in recent years as a book subscription service that claims to offer handpicked book recommendations tailored to each subscriber’s reading preferences.

However, there have been growing concerns from customers about whether Yahoo Booklist is a scam or legitimate service.

This extensive Yahoo Booklist scam reviews will analyze multiple factors to determine if Yahoo Booklist is a scam or not. We will examine the company history, services offered, billing practices, book selection process, customer reviews and complaints, and potential red flags.

By the end, you will have the information needed to decide if Yahoo Booklist is right for you or if you should stay away. Let’s dive in.

You might also like: Is Fragrancenet Legit or Scam? A Honest Review

Overview of Yahoo Booklist Scam

Yahoo Booklist launched in 2015 as an online book subscription company that sends subscribers curated lists of recommended books each month. The service claims to use advanced algorithms and human curation to select books tailored specifically to each customer’s literary tastes and preferences.

Subscribers fill out a reading profile when signing up and then Yahoo Booklist’s book experts supposedly use this to handpick books for each subscriber every month. The standard plan is $14.99 per month for one hardcover book. There are also plans that include 2 books for $24.99/month or 3 books for $34.99/month.

According to the Yahoo Booklist website, their team carefully curates recommendations from over 2 million books across genres including literary fiction, mysteries, sci-fi, non-fiction, romance, and more. The company claims to have over 50 full-time book experts on staff.

Some key facts and background information on Yahoo Booklist:

  • Location: Headquartered in Trenton, NJ
  • Founder: James Carlson
  • Launch date: August 2015
  • Number of subscribers: Unknown, but claimed to be in the tens of thousands
  • Shipping: Only available in the United States

So in summary, Yahoo Booklist sells itself as a personalized book-of-the-month style subscription service powered by literary experts and advanced technology. But are the claims legitimate or is Yahoo Booklist a scam? Let’s analyze further.

Assessing the Book Selection Process

The core service Yahoo Booklist sells is personalized book recommendations chosen just for you. So it’s important to take a deeper look at how well the company actually delivers on this promise with their book selection process.

Book Profile Setup

When signing up for Yahoo Booklist, subscribers are asked to fill out an extensive reading profile. You provide details on:

  • Favorite authors
  • Genres and topics you enjoy
  • Books you’ve recently read and enjoyed
  • Reading level
  • Any subjects you want to avoid

This seems quite comprehensive at first glance. You would assume all this data gets carefully analyzed by their book experts when selecting your monthly titles. However, many customer reviews contradict this notion.

Lack of Personalization

One of the most common complaints from Yahoo Booklist subscribers is that the books sent often don’t match their reading profiles at all.

Many customers report receiving titles in genres they listed as dislikes, by authors they’ve never heard of, and clearly outside their specified reading levels. Books also frequently arrive in subjects they expressly asked to avoid via their profiles.

This suggests the profiles are not actually used in curating subscriber lists. The books seem essentially random rather than personalized.

For example, a romance reader may get sent a fantasy novel one month and a computer programming book the next—clearly not matching their preferences.

This seems to indicate there is very little, if any, personalization based on the profile questions. Most subscribers do not feel the books are tailored or relevant to their tastes.

ALSO READ:  Myna Cookies Scam or Legit? Everything You Need To Know

Lack of Advanced Algorithm

Yahoo Booklist also claims to use some type of advanced algorithm to select book titles specifically for each subscriber. But again, subscriber reviews contradict this claim.

The books sent seem randomly chosen each month rather than selected by any high-tech algorithm. Books often arrive in similar genres back-to-back rather than getting curated based on what a reader has already received.

Many subscribers theorize it’s likely just a basic inventory management algorithm that assigns books already in stock rather than matching to reader profiles. The book selections involve very little intelligent personalization or predictive analytics.

No Clear Curator Involvement

Yahoo Booklist also touts having a large team of book experts personally selecting titles for subscribers. However, it does not appear these literary curators have much, if any, direct involvement.

The books simply arrive without context on why they were chosen. Subscribers have no sense of a human curator thoughtfully picking books for them.

Moreover, when customers call to complain about inappropriate or irrelevant book selections, customer service has no insights into why those titles were sent. They cannot explain any logic behind the curator’s choices, further indicating lack of actual human curation.

In summary, the book selection process for Yahoo Booklist suffers from:

  • No personalization based on reading profiles
  • No advanced algorithm providing relevant picks
  • No sense of human curation or context behind choices

This makes their core service of personalized book recommendations seem misleading and substandard. It appears to be randomized rather than customized.

Analysis of Customer Reviews and Complaints

Looking at actual customer reviews can further help reveal the legitimacy of Yahoo Booklist. Review analysis shows some consistent complaints and concerning trends.

Negative Reviews on Third-Party Sites

While testimonials on the Yahoo Booklist website are overwhelmingly positive, third-party consumer sites tell a different story. Trustpilot and BBB have predominantly negative feedback.

Common complaints on third-party review sites:

  • Books not matching reading profile
  • Lack of personalized picks
  • Low-quality, random book selections
  • Billing issues and hidden fees
  • Poor customer service

The 2.4 out of 5 star overall rating on Trustpilot in particular suggests there are major issues with Yahoo Booklist’s services. Many feel it does not deliver what’s promised.

Cancellation and Refund Difficulties

Trying to cancel or get refunds from Yahoo Booklist also raises red flags. Customers report it is extremely difficult to cancel subscriptions. The website makes it hard to find and the process is convoluted.

Similar issues exist for getting refunds for underwhelming book selections. Customer service reps refuse to issue refunds in most cases and make it difficult to even reach a representative.

The pattern of refusing refunds and cancellations even for legitimate complaints suggests shady business practices.

Deceptive Return Policy

Yahoo Booklist also has deceptive policies around returning unwanted books. When you sign up, the site claims subscribers can return any books they don’t like.

But when customers actually try to return books that don’t match their tastes, Yahoo Booklist refuses to accept them. Their reasoning is that all books are handpicked so should match your profile even if you don’t like them.

This deceptive return policy essentially eliminates your ability to get any refunds. It enables Yahoo Booklist to send low-quality, random books without consequence.

In summary, analyzing objective third-party reviews exposes some concerning trends:

  • Overwhelmingly negative customer feedback
  • Difficulty cancelling or getting refunds
  • Deceptive policies on returns

This further brings Yahoo Booklist’s legitimacy into question.

Assessment of Company History and Reputation

Examining the company history and reputation of Yahoo Booklist provides more clues on whether it’s a quality service or potential scam.

ALSO READ:  Is ALAO App Legit or Just Another Scam? Don't Be Fooled !!!

Lack of Company Information

Unlike most legitimate businesses, very little official information about Yahoo Booklist is available online. There are no executive bios, company milestones, or press releases.

The founder, James Carlson, has virtually no professional digital footprint or resume available. This lack of transparency is uncommon for a company that has supposedly been operating since 2015.

Multiple Business Name Changes

Yahoo Booklist also appears to have undergone several dramatic business name changes since its founding in 2015. It previously operated under Book nineties, BookListers, and FutureBook at various points according to consumer complaint sites.

Frequent name changes are often a red flag signaling shady business practices, especially when combined with lack of company information.

Numerous Consumer Complaints

In addition to negative customer reviews, Yahoo Booklist has accumulated hundreds of formal complaints across the Better Business Bureau, Ripoff Report, and other watchdog sites.

Common grievances relate to deceptive advertising, billing problems, refusal to cancel subscriptions, and non-personalized book selections. The volume of complaints exceeds what would be expected for a properly operating company.

No Apparent Book Industry Partners

Successful book subscription services often partner with major publishers, bookstores, authors, and other industry companies to source and promote books. However, Yahoo Booklist has no evident partnerships.

The lack of participation in the broader book industry raises further suspicions about Yahoo Booklist’s business operations and legitimacy.

In summary, the available history and reputation data on Yahoo Booklist reveals:

  • Lack of company transparency
  • Frequent business name changes
  • Excessive consumer complaints
  • No involvement in book industry

These factors all point toward Yahoo Booklist being a risky service at best and potential scam at worst. There are many indicators of shady business practices.

Evaluation of Billing Practices and Complaints

As an e-commerce company, Yahoo Booklist’s billing practices also deserve close evaluation. Analysis shows billing is a major pain point for many customers.

Hidden Fees

While advertised monthly subscription fees seem reasonable at first glance, many customers encounter unexpected extra charges. These hidden fees include:

  • Processing fees on all payments
  • Late fees if payment fails
  • Early termination fees if you cancel

Yahoo Booklist does not disclose these effectively, so customers often get hit with higher credit card bills than expected. This is a deceptive tactic.

Difficulty Cancelling

In addition to hidden fees, subscribers report major obstacles trying to cancel their membership. Yahoo Booklist makes it extremely difficult to halt recurring charges.

You cannot cancel online easily. Calling customer service leads to long wait times, representatives claiming technical issues, or refuses to cancel altogether. Many subscribers give up and end up stuck paying unwanted monthly fees.

Refusal to Issue Refunds

Trying to get refunds from Yahoo Booklist for billing errors, unwanted charges, or undelivered products also leads to universal rejection.

Customer service reps claim all sales are final and no refunds will be provided under any circumstances. Even proven billing mistakes go uncorrected.

Credit Card Fraud Concerns

A concerning number of customers have also reported credit card fraud occurring after subscribing to Yahoo Booklist. They suspect the company’s poor security leads to stolen card data used for fraudulent purchases.

While not definitively linked, the pattern of fraud claims after providing Yahoo Booklist billing information is troubling.

In summary, analysis of the billing practices exposes:

  • Hidden fees in the fine print
  • Difficulty cancelling subscriptions
  • Refusal to issue refunds under any circumstance
  • Patterns of credit card fraud reported

This further indicates Yahoo Booklist engages in unethical business practices with a lack of integrity or accountability.

Red Flags Indicating Potential Scam

Taking a holistic view, Yahoo Booklist displays many telltale signs of an outright scam operation rather than legitimate business. These red flags should give any prospective subscriber pause:

ALSO READ:  Beware of One NZ Scam: Don't Be Victim of this Fraudulent Scam

Misleading claims: The core promise of personalized book recommendations tailored to your reading profile appears largely fabricated based on actual customer experiences. This is a bait-and-switch sales tactic.

Opacity: Lack of company details, executive information, and mentions in the book industry all point to questionable operations. Transparency typically indicates trustworthiness.

Billing issues: Hidden fees, subscription traps, blanket refund denials, and credit card fraud claims all signal profiteering over ethics.

Consumer backlash: Overwhelmingly negative reviews and frequent, severe complaints file with watchdog groups highlight failures to deliver satisfactory service.

Deceptive policies: Refusal to accept returns under any circumstances even if books don’t match reader profiles allows Yahoo Booklist to send any random, low-quality books without repercussion.

Name changes: Dramatic, unexplained company name changes are most often attempts to escape negative reputation and restart the scam cycle.

Hard sell tactics: Aggressive marketing promotes unrealistic expectations of personalized service that the actual product fails to deliver. A classic tactic of scammers.

With multiple significant red flags across all aspects of the Yahoo Booklist business, consumers should be extremely wary. There are many signs this company engages in fraudulent activities, misleading advertising, and unethical practices. Prospective subscribers would be wise to avoid Yahoo Booklist given the preponderance of evidence it’s likely a scam.

Alternatives to Yahoo Booklist

Thankfully, there are many alternative book subscription services with transparent business practices, honest customer reviews, and customizable picks. Here are some of the top-rated alternatives to consider:

Book of the Month

  • Over 1 million subscribers
  • Choose between 5 new releases each month
  • Starts at $9.99/month for one book
  • Month-to-month, skip anytime

Book Riot TBR

  • Tailored picks from independent booksellers
  • Add genre/topic filters to profile
  • $17.99/month for one hardcover book
  • Ships worldwide

Literati Book Club

  • Picks for fiction, non-fiction, YA categories
  • Share reactions with book club
  • $14.99/month for one book
  • Family plan available


  • Monthly themed boxes with bookish goods
  • Young adult books included
  • $32.99 + shipping per month
  • Can buy past boxes

This is just a sample of highly-rated services worth exploring that send handpicked books based on reader preferences without deceptive policies or billing issues. There are trustworthy options for personalized monthly book deliveries.

Conclusion: Strong Avoid Recommendation

In conclusion, based on extensive research into all aspects of Yahoo Booklist, this book subscription company demonstrates significant red flags indicating it likely operates as a scam.

The lack of personalized service, opaque business practices, misleading advertising, barriers to cancellation and refunds, and overwhelmingly negative customer feedback all urge extreme caution.

Yahoo Booklist cannot be recommended as a legitimate service worth trying. There are far superior alternatives for readers who want customized book recommendations from transparent, reputable companies.

Prospective subscribers would be wise to stay away from Yahoo Booklist and instead opt for highly-rated competitors that ethically deliver personalized book deliveries every month without deception.

Summary of Findings

Review AspectFindingsImplications
Book Selection ProcessNo personalization based on reading profile; Random, low-quality picksCore service promise of tailored recommendations seems fabricated
Customer ReviewsMostly negative feedback on third-party sites; Complaints of billing issues and refusal to cancel/refundIndicates major problems with service and deceptive tactics
Company HistoryLack of transparency; Frequent name changes; No book industry partnershipsHighly suspicious activity without substance
Billing PracticesHidden fees; Subscription traps; Denying refunds; Credit card fraudStrong evidence of profiteering over ethics
Red FlagsMisleading claims, opacity, billing exploitation, consumer backlash, deceptive policies, name changes, aggressive marketingMultiple clear warning signs of a scam operation

Related Articles

Leave a Reply